American XL Bully dog portrait, dangerous dog breeds, myths and UK laws

Dangerous Dog Breeds: Myths, Laws & Responsible Ownership

Time to read 4 min

The concept of “dangerous dog breeds” is controversial, as behaviour depends on training, socialisation, and environment.

Some breeds, including the Pit Bull Terrier and Japanese Tosa, are banned under UK law.

Dog aggression is often linked to owner responsibility, poor training, and neglect rather than breed.

Understanding dog behaviour, early socialisation, and proper training reduces the risk of aggressive incidents.

Breed-specific legislation (BSL) is debated globally, with calls for responsible ownership laws instead.

The term “dangerous dog breeds” is widely debated. While some breeds have gained a reputation for aggression, experts agree that a dog’s behaviour is primarily shaped by training, socialisation, and environment rather than genetics alone.


In the UK, the Dangerous Dogs Act 1991 was introduced to ban certain breeds considered high-risk. However, animal welfare organisations, such as the RSPCA and The Kennel Club, argue that focusing on breed alone does little to prevent dog attacks and instead advocate for responsible pet ownership laws.


This guide will explore which breeds are legally restricted in the UK, debunk common myths surrounding so-called "dangerous" breeds, and discuss how responsible training and handling play a crucial role in preventing aggression.

What Defines a Dangerous Dog Breed?

A dangerous dog breed is typically defined as a breed with a reputation for aggression or attacks. However, breed alone does not determine a dog’s behaviour: environment, training, and socialisation play significant roles.

Factors Contributing to a Dog’s Aggressive Reputation

While some breeds require experienced handling, no breed is inherently aggressive. Proper training and socialisation from an early age play the most critical role in shaping a dog’s temperament.


  • Bite Strength & Physical Capability: Large, muscular breeds with strong jaws can cause more severe injuries.

  • Historical Usage: Some breeds were originally bred for guarding or hunting, which contributes to their reputation.

  • Recorded Incidents: Certain breeds appear in dog bite statistics more frequently, but this often correlates with their popularity rather than their temperament.

Dogo Argentino resting outdoors, one of the breeds often affected by dangerous dog laws.

List of Restricted or Banned Dog Breeds

In the UK, the Dangerous Dogs Act 1991 bans or restricts the ownership of certain breeds. As of 2024, the following breeds are banned unless exempt:

Banned Dog Breeds in the UK

  1. Pit Bull Terrier – A breed historically used for dog fighting.

  2. Japanese Tosa – A rare breed bred for fighting in Japan.

  3. Dogo Argentino – A large hunting breed with strong protective instincts.

  4. Fila Brasileiro – A Brazilian mastiff known for its guarding abilities.

  5. XL Bully (as of February 2024) – Recently added due to concerns over attacks.

In response to a series of fatal attacks involving American XL Bully dogs, the UK government implemented a ban on the breed. Effective from 1 February 2024, it is illegal to own an XL Bully in England and Wales without a Certificate of Exemption.

Owners of exempted dogs must adhere to strict conditions, including neutering, microchipping, obtaining third-party insurance, and ensuring the dog is muzzled and on a lead in public.

Other Breeds with Restrictions Globally

In some countries, breeds like Rottweilers, Doberman Pinschers, and Akitas are restricted under dangerous dog laws, requiring specific ownership conditions.

Are These Breeds Truly Dangerous? Debunking the Myths

Many "dangerous dog" labels are based on misconceptions rather than science. Here are some of the most common myths:

Myth 1: Some Breeds Are Naturally Aggressive

  • Reality: No breed is born aggressive. A dog’s behaviour is shaped by training, environment, and socialisation.

Myth 2: Bigger Dogs Are More Dangerous

  • Reality: While larger breeds can cause more damage, smaller breeds (such as Chihuahuas) often display more frequent aggression but receive less scrutiny.

Myth 3: Banning Certain Breeds Reduces Dog Attacks

  • Reality: Studies show that breed-specific legislation (BSL) has little impact on reducing dog attacks. Responsible ownership laws are more effective.
American XL Bully dog standing confidently, frequently debated in dog breed legislation.

Understanding Breed-Specific Legislation (BSL)

Breed-specific legislation (BSL) refers to laws targeting certain breeds based on perceived aggression risks.


Pros of BSL:

  • Aims to reduce dog attacks.

  • Creates awareness of responsible ownership.


Cons of BSL:

  • Discriminates against specific breeds rather than addressing real causes of aggression.

  • Leads to the unnecessary euthanasia of well-behaved dogs.

  • Focuses on breed rather than owner responsibility.


Most animal welfare organisations advocate for behaviour-based assessments rather than breed bans.

Responsible Dog Ownership & Preventing Aggression

Regardless of breed, responsible pet ownership is key to preventing aggression.

1. Early Socialisation & Training

  • Introduce dogs to various environments and people.

  • Use reward-based training rather than punishment.


2. Supervision & Secure Handling

  • Always supervise interactions between dogs and children.

  • Use proper leashes and enclosures in public spaces.


3. Regular Vet Care & Neutering

  • Regular health checks can identify medical conditions that may cause aggression.

  • Neutering may help reduce aggressive tendencies in some dogs.


4. Education for Owners

  • Understand breed-specific needs before adopting.

  • Avoid using harsh training methods, as these can increase fear-based aggression.

Staffordshire Bull Terrier playing fetch, showcasing the playful nature of so-called dangerous dog breeds.

While certain breeds are labelled as dangerous, no dog is born aggressive. Training, environment, and responsible ownership play the most crucial roles in shaping a dog’s behaviour.


Instead of focusing on breed bans, effective laws should promote education, responsible pet ownership, and stricter penalties for neglectful handling. If you are considering adopting a breed with a strong reputation, invest in proper training and socialisation to ensure a safe and well-behaved companion.

While we strive to provide accurate and up-to-date information, this blog is for informational purposes only and is not intended as a substitute for professional veterinary advice, diagnosis, or treatment. Always consult a licensed veterinarian for personalised guidance regarding your pet's health. We are not responsible for any decisions or actions taken based on the information provided in this blog.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the most dangerous dog breed?

No breed is inherently dangerous, but breeds with strong physical traits, such as Pit Bulls and Rottweilers, require experienced handling.

Can I own a banned breed in the UK?

Only with an exemption certificate proving responsible ownership and proper containment measures.

Does breed-specific legislation (BSL) work?

Research suggests BSL does not effectively reduce dog attacks . Stronger ownership laws and education are more effective solutions.

Are banned dog breeds always aggressive?

Not necessarily. Many banned breeds can be friendly and well-behaved with responsible training and socialisation.

Leave a comment